Microsoft Office 2007 for Windows versus Microsoft Office 2008 for Mac

I have a copy of MS Office 2007 for Windows and a copy of MS Office 2008 for Mac. I have used both. One is clearly superior to the other.

The winner: MS Office 2007 for Windows. Despite a release date over a year after Office 2007 launched, Office 2008 for the Mac barely compares. Office 2007 was a radical, new, and useful version of Office. The ribbon throughout is very nice.  Word is especially different. Outlook had a wonderful new feature — drag emails directly into your calendar. For a detailed review, go to here.

Office 2008 for Mac foregos many of the radical changes found in Office 2007. Word seems barely changed. Entourage is a pale comparison of Outlook and I can’t drag my emails into calendar events. Powerpoint has improved. The only major benefit of 2008 is that it is faster than Office 2004 for Mac because now it is native to the Intel platform. Underwhelming. For a detailed review, go here.

I wonder why MS did not simply convert MS Office 2007 for Windows into a Mac version. It probably would have saved them some work since it would just be code conversion to work on a new OS. Instead, by creating MS Office 2008 for Mac, MS now has two totally separate Office programs that need separate support functions. Why?

My guess is that MS is scared of the resurgence in the Mac platform. If business people saw that they could have the exact same Office platform on Mac as they could on Windows, it would make switching an easier decision. Now, that switch becomes more difficult to make. A business person who has put a lot of time into learning Office for Windows programs is going to have a learning curve when switching to the Mac editions. These editions also seem slightly less functional. Why spend the effort? Maybe they will just stick with Windows, instead.


3 thoughts on “Microsoft Office 2007 for Windows versus Microsoft Office 2008 for Mac

  1. What kind of review is this? do you don’t mention anything about feature wise, you said office 2008 mac faster than 2004. Have you even use 2004. Office 2008 is a memory hog, i can’t even run it on my ibook g4, where office 2004 run smoothly. Feature wise, mac version of office is a big change. new template, new wage of changing content. stop with your bullshit man

  2. I was using Office 2007 and now 2008, i miss the “preview” thing, like been working and then pre-see the effect of the edit in windows… but still, parallel desktops!!! jjijijiji

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s